Alex Smith

**Biggin** · October 16th, 2011, 07:48 PM

Originally Posted by R13

That's a big stretch, his ratings are up there so far(he has much lower attempts/completions), but he's lucky to be top 15.

His team is 5-1, and he has only turned the ball over 5 times and has a rating of 104. Please show me these 15 QBs that are playing better than him right now. Two comebacks ON THE ROAD against the Dream Team and the undefeated Lions

**R13** · October 16th, 2011, 08:27 PM

2011 NFL Player Passing Stats - National Football League - ESPN

Ratings is the only thing he is top 5 in and with one pick, but his attempts are also a lot lower too.

Look at that stat list and there's no way he's top 5, what would lead anyone to believe he was looking at column after column?

**1inStripes** · October 16th, 2011, 09:43 PM

I remember when Trent Dilfer was a top 5 QB for the Ravens too......

**Biggin** · October 16th, 2011, 10:15 PM

Originally Posted by R13

2011 NFL Player Passing Stats - National Football League - ESPN

Ratings is the only thing he is top 5 in and with one pick, but his attempts are also a lot lower too.

Look at that stat list and there's no way he's top 5, what would lead anyone to believe he was looking at column after column?

Once again, show me these 15 quarterbacks playing better than Alex Smith right now....

Aaron Rodgers? Absolutely, he is >>Smith no question.
Brady? Same
Brees? Sure, but his team hasnt played as well as Smith's.

There are a couple more I could put ahead of Smith, but I am very interested to see who you list as playing better than Smith so far this season.

And are we going to punish a QB because he doesnt throw it 40 times a game now?

**UTVols2** · October 16th, 2011, 10:25 PM

What did everyone think of the coaches going at it after the game? From what I saw Harbaugh did go a little overboard and should have been a little more calm at the handshake but Schwartz went overboard as well. Should have just ran up, said his peace, and walked away instead of letting it get out of control. And did anybody see Vandy's James Franlkin and UGA DC going at it, I missed it and can't find a video. For some reason, Franklin really gets on my nerves.

**Biggin** · October 17th, 2011, 01:44 AM

yeah I saw them both and biased in both situations haha, but I thought Schwartz escalated the event and made it into a big deal by chasing after Harbaugh. He spoke about protocol, yet its definitely not protocol to chase after somebody. Harbaugh was def intense with the handshake, but Schwartz had made a gesture towards the SF sidelines earlier in the game. Detroit is also not the classiest bunch in the NFL on the field, but SF is not one to shy away from physicality.

And Franklin said something to Shawn Williams, UGA defender who had two personal fouls during the game and at least two more very borderline plays that were not called, and Grantham got pissed. Franklin probably should not have said something to a player but Grantham again escalated the event by getting all in Franklins face. This one I believe its more even, Franklin was out of line but Grantham went nuts.